Tuesday, May 21, 2024

CJI Ramana expresses anguish over media reports on collegium recommendations, calls it ‘unfortunate’, ‘irresponsible reporting’

Chief Justice of India N. V. Ramana on Wednesday expressed his anguish and concerns over certain speculations and reports in the media regarding the Collegium recommendations for the appointment of Supreme Court judges, even before the selection process was finalised.

Justice Ramana expressed his concern regarding the matter during the farewell meet of Justice Navin Sinha, on his superannuation in the ceremonial bench, which also comprised of Justices Surya Kant and Aniruddha Bose. 

Justice Ramana said, “You are all aware we need to appoint judges to this court. The process is ongoing. Meetings will be held and decisions will be taken. The process of appointment of judges is sacrosanct and has certain dignity attached to it. My media friends must understand and recognise the sanctity of this process.

“As an Institution, we hold the freedom of media and the rights of individuals in high esteem. Today’s reflections in some sections of the media, pending the process, even before formalising the resolution is counter-productive. There were instances of deserving career progression of bright talents getting marred because of such irresponsible reporting and speculation. This is very unfortunate and I am extremely upset about it,” he added. 

The CJI further said, “I must also place on record tremendous amount of maturity and responsibility displayed by majority of the senior journalists and media houses in showing restraint and not speculating on such a serious matter. Such professional journalists and ethical media are the real strength of the Supreme Court in particular and democracy in general. You are part of our system. I expect all the stakeholders to uphold the integrity and dignity of this institution.

“I am sure Brother Sinha will forgive for deviating a bit on this solemn occasion. He will understand my anguish. I firmly believe that the nation will continue to draw benefit of Brother Sinha’s rich experience. I look forward to his continued contributions in the legal field. On behalf of all my Brother and Sister Judges, I wish him all the best for his future endeavours,” he added.

The CJI expressed his anger towards the news that has been published in the media regarding the Appointments of Judges to the Supreme Court, which was passed and recommended by the Supreme Court Collegium. As per reports, the Supreme Court Collegium cleared nine names for appointment to Supreme Court, including three women judges:

1) Justice Hima Kohli

2) Justice B. V. Nagarathna 

3) Justice Bela Trivedi 

4) One from bar – Senior Advocate P. S. Narsimha 

5) Justice A. S. Oka 

6) Justice Vikram Nath 

7) Justice J. K. Maheshwari 

8) Justice C. T. Ravindrakumar 

9) Justice M. M. Sunderesh 

During the e-farewell, Justice Ramana said, “Brother Sinha’s knowledge and wisdom are writ large in all his judgments. However, the qualities I most admire in him are his humility and simplicity. He never makes anyone feel less or unworthy. These attributes were clear in the way Brother Sinha always conducted his Court. He was always well prepared for Court and knew the contents of every file. Yet, he gave people a patient hearing, be they juniors or seniors. For young advocates, I am sure arguing before Brother Sinha must have been a wonderful experience.

Also Read: Delhi court drops charges against Shashi Tharoor in Sunanda Pushkar death case

“Brother Sinha is known by the Bar and Bench for his straightforward and candid approach. He will always be remembered as a fair Judge- one who talks less, but is very insightful. Personally, I am left feeling quite saddened by his retirement. We are losing an important voice and a valued colleague,” he added. 

Senior Advocate Pradeep Rai and Vice President of the Supreme Court Bar Association said, “It is my honour and privilege to address this gathering to celebrate the awe-inspiring journey Justice Sinha has had till now.

“After being appointed on February 17, 2017, he has served this sacred institution for four-and-a-half years. On this very occasion, I want to express gratitude to his Lordship on behalf of the members of the Bar on utmost steadiness, humility, integrity, hard work, fairness and uprightness of his Lordship,” added Mr Rai. 

He gave a brief account of Justice Sinha’s life and said Justice Sinha completed his school from Patna in 1972 and moved to New Delhi for his graduation from Hindu College. He did his LLB from Campus Law Centre of the Faculty of Law, University of Delhi, in 1979.

“His alma mater has given us many judges. Vivek Tankha, former AG of MP and Member of Parliament; Sumit Kachwaha, Nina Gupta our EC member; Justice Navniti Prasad Singh, a senior advocate and member of our bar. Madhu Saran, along with Justice Nariman who retired recently, were classmates of Justice Sinha,” revealed Rai.

He said Justice Navniti Prasad Singh used to drive a Rajdoot and Justice Navin Sinha used to drive a Jawa Yezdi, which was in fashion during those days. They used to go together, whereas Justice Nariman used to drive a Luna moped.

Rai further said that apart from hearing cases, a Judge is also saddled with many administrative duties. Justice Sinha’s emphasis on technology and digital revolution in dispute resolution has been a boost for efficiency.

Also Read: Supreme Court starts hearing on plea challenging new TRAI amendments related to MRP of individual channels

In December 2020, while delivering a special address in an event organised by NITI Ayog and Patna High Court for advancing access to justice through Online Dispute Resolution, in the context of post-pandemic world, Justice Sinha had very aptly stated that it is essential to ensure all stakeholders are trained and prepared for this new normal. “We will be successful in ensuring justice delivery for all by taking a collaborative route as the way forward,” added Rai. 

He said, “Justice Sinha is also credited with championing the computerisation of Patna, Chhattisgarh and Rajasthan High Courts. During his tenure, Chhattisgarh High Court became the second in the country to introduce payment of court fee electronically. Subsequently, the e-Court fees centre at Jaipur was also inaugurated by him, making Rajasthan High Court the fourth in the country to provide e-stamp facility.”


News Update